A Good Nudge Has a Specific Assumption
Anchored to: Thaler and Sunstein’s choice architecture and the paycheck-margin assumption behind default savings
I want to say something good about nudges first, because the credit is deserved.
Behavioral economics corrected a real mistake. People aren’t calculators. The way a choice is presented shapes what we pick, and Thaler and Sunstein (2008) showed how thoughtful design, like automatic enrollment in a retirement plan, can move millions of people toward saving without asking anyone to try harder.
Now the assumption inside the best-known examples. A default savings rule works on a paycheck with a margin in it. It takes a little off the top of income that exceeds the month’s costs, before the person has a chance to spend it.
Where income doesn’t cover the month, there’s nothing for the default to act on. You can set the architecture perfectly and the money still isn’t there. That isn’t a flaw in the research. It’s a boundary of where the tool applies, and the people most often handed the tool sit outside it.
I think the discipline would be stronger if it said so plainly, and a lot of its own scholars do. My argument isn’t that nudges are wrong. It’s that a design built for people with a margin shouldn’t be the default design for people without one.
A better-fitting version might look different. It could mean building the margin first, through emergency assistance, income supports, or a stretch of stability, and only then automating what’s left. It could also mean pairing any default with a structural question about the paycheck itself. Behavioral tools can be very good at what they were built for. Matching the tool to the situation is the part that takes judgment.
I go through this in the second half of this week’s episode.
What’s a nudge that worked well in your setting, and who was it built for?